VT 
Contango and backwardation are terms used in futures trading to describe how contract prices relate to the current market (spot) price. These pricing patterns offer key insights into supply, demand, and market sentiment. Whether you’re trading oil, gold, or commodity ETFs, understanding the difference between contango and backwardation can shape how you manage positions and assess risk. In this article, we’ll explain what these terms mean, what causes them, how they differ, and how traders and investors can apply this knowledge in real-world scenarios.
What Does Contango Mean?
Contango is a market condition where futures prices are higher than the current spot price. Contango refers to a situation in which the price for a commodity to be delivered at a future date is above the price available in the spot market, where immediate delivery occurs. In simple terms, it means you’re paying more for delivery in the future than if you bought the commodity today.
This usually happens when the cost of holding or storing the asset—such as storage costs, insurance costs, and interest rates—is factored into the price. Markets often experience contango when there is no immediate shortage or supply disruption, and future prices reflect normal storage and carry costs.
Example of Contango:
Contango often appears in the crude oil market when supply is abundant and demand is stable or declining. Brent crude oil is a classic example of a commodity that often trades in contango. For instance, if the spot price of oil is $75 per barrel, but a futures contract for delivery in six months (the future date) is priced at $78, the market is in contango. This price difference reflects the storage, insurance, and financing costs associated with holding the physical commodity until delivery. In this scenario, the futures curve is typically an upward-sloping forward curve, where the future price or forward price for a future date is higher than the current spot price, and is compared to the expected spot price at the time of contract expiration.
What Does Backwardation Mean?
Backwardation is the opposite of contango. It occurs when futures prices are lower than the current spot price, creating a market known as a backwardation. In such a market, the futures curve is typically a downward-sloping curve, reflecting market expectations that prices will fall or that there is a supply-demand imbalance. Backwardation can also occur when the futures price is below the expected future spot price, a situation referred to as normal backwardation. This is often explained by Keynesian theory, where the difference between the futures price and the expected future spot price represents a risk premium earned by speculators for taking on price risk. Additionally, convenience yield—the benefit or incentive for holding the physical commodity now rather than later due to anticipated supply disruptions or tight supply conditions—can contribute to backwardation.
Backwardation tends to favor long positions, as futures prices often rise and converge with the spot price before expiry. This creates what’s known as a positive roll yield, which can enhance returns over time.
Example of Backwardation:
Backwardation is common in natural gas markets during periods of high seasonal demand. For example, if the spot price of natural gas rises to $5.00 per MMBtu due to increased heating needs, while a futures contract for delivery a few months later is priced at $4.30, the market is in backwardation. This reflects strong near-term demand, the influence of convenience yield, and expectations of lower prices once the short-term pressure eases. The difference between the futures price and the expected future spot price may also include a risk premium, further contributing to the backwardation structure.
What Causes Contango and Backwardation?
Several factors can influence whether a market is in contango or backwardation:
1. Storage and Insurance Costs
Storage costs and insurance costs are significant factors, especially in commodity futures and commodity futures markets. These costs are incurred to hold the underlying commodity until the delivery date, and they are reflected in the delivery price of the futures or forward contract. As the delivery date approaches, the futures price and spot price tend to converge.
2. Financing Costs and Interest Rates
Financing costs and interest rates are also part of the total cost structure for future delivery of the underlying asset. In both futures markets and forward contracts, these costs are included in the calculation of forward prices and delivery prices, impacting the price differences between spot and futures prices.
3. Expectations of Future Supply and Demand
Investors anticipate changes in future supply and demand, which affect the expected future price and expected spot price of the underlying commodity. These expectations are reflected in the pricing of futures contracts, forward contracts, and forward prices.
4. Contract Structure and Expiration
The structure of futures contracts and forward contracts includes specific expiration dates, expiry dates, and delivery dates. As the contract expires or the futures contract expires, the futures price and spot price converge, and the delivery price becomes equal to the spot price. This convergence is a key feature of both futures and forward contracts.
5. Arbitrage and Price Risk
Price risk and price differences between spot and futures prices create opportunities for market participants to sell futures contracts or engage in arbitrage. In the futures market and commodity futures markets, these activities help align prices and manage risk for both speculators and hedgers.
For example, in extreme market conditions, the current futures price and current price can diverge significantly, reflecting the impact of storage costs, financing costs, and market expectations. In normal market conditions (contango), futures prices are above spot prices, and as the delivery date or expiry date approaches, prices converge.
Contango vs Backwardation: What Are the Key Differences?
The key differences between contango and backwardation lie in how they reflect market expectations and trading conditions. As a futures contract approaches expiration, spot and futures prices tend to move closer together, eventually meeting at the contract’s expiry. The table below highlights the main contrasts between the two pricing structures.
| Aspect | Contango | Backwardation |
| Price Relationship | Futures price > Spot price | Futures price < Spot price |
| Market Condition | Surplus or stable supply | Tight supply or rising demand |
| Trader Impact | Negative roll yield | Positive roll yield |
| Common in | Energy, gold in stable periods | Agriculture, energy in crisis |
| Risks | Costly rollovers in ETFs | Limited availability or volatility |
1. Price Relationship
In a contango market, the futures price is higher than the spot price. This reflects the costs associated with holding or storing the asset until delivery. The delivery price reflects the agreed cost of the commodity upon settlement, aligning futures and spot prices as the contract nears expiry. Traders expect prices to rise gradually toward the futures price as the contract matures. In backwardation, the futures price is lower than the spot price, meaning immediate delivery is more expensive. This often signals strong current demand or limited supply.
2. Market Condition
Contango typically occurs when the market is well-supplied and stable. There is no immediate need for the commodity, so traders price in the cost of carrying the asset into the future. In contrast, backwardation suggests a tight market where supply is constrained or demand is surging. It reflects urgency — buyers are willing to pay more now rather than wait.
3. Trader Impact and Roll Yield
Contango can be costly for traders and investors who roll over futures contracts. As each expiring contract is replaced by a more expensive one, the strategy generates a negative roll yield, reducing overall returns. Backwardation, on the other hand, often produces a positive roll yield. Traders benefit as futures prices tend to rise and converge with the spot price before expiry, effectively boosting returns.
4. Common Markets and Conditions
Contango is often observed in markets with high storage capacity and low short-term demand, such as crude oil or gold during calm economic periods. Backwardation is more common in commodities sensitive to seasonal demand or geopolitical stress, such as natural gas during winter or agricultural products during supply disruptions.
5. Risks and Challenges
In contango, investors in commodity-based ETFs or funds may experience performance drag due to repeated rollovers into higher-priced contracts. This is especially problematic for long-term holders. In backwardation, while roll yield can be positive, the market may be volatile and unpredictable. Prices may reflect panic buying or unexpected supply shocks, which pose risks of their own.
How Traders and Investors Use Contango and Backwardation
Understanding whether a market is in contango or backwardation helps traders and investors make more informed decisions about when to enter or exit a position, and how to manage risk. Analyzing price movements and futures curves allows investors to identify opportunities and risks in contango and backwardation markets.
In a contango environment, futures prices are higher than spot prices, which can erode profits over time through negative roll yield. This is especially important for short-term traders or ETF investors, as rolling into higher-priced contracts repeatedly can reduce performance. As a result, traders in contango markets often limit their holding periods or seek alternative strategies like calendar spreads to manage the cost of rollover.
In backwardation, futures prices are lower than the current spot price. This can work in favor of long-term holders because of the positive roll yield — as contracts move toward expiry, they tend to rise and converge with the spot price, offering a potential return boost. Traders often see backwardation as a sign of near-term scarcity, which can lead to more confident or aggressive long positions.
For investors using commodity ETFs or funds tied to futures (such as oil, gas, or metals), the shape of the futures curve matters significantly. ETFs that roll contracts monthly can suffer in contango, while they tend to perform better in backwardation. Monitoring curve structures regularly helps investors avoid underperformance and align with market conditions more effectively.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Contango
Contango affects traders and investors in different ways depending on their strategy and holding period. Below are the key advantages and disadvantages of operating in a contango market.
Advantages of Contango
1. Predictable and Stable Markets
Contango often reflects normal market conditions where supply is sufficient and prices move steadily over time. This predictability can benefit institutions or hedgers seeking long-term exposure.
2. Useful for Hedging Long-Term Contracts
Producers and commercial users can lock in future prices above current levels, helping them budget and protect against price drops.
3. Reflects Full Cost Structure
The futures price in contango includes storage, insurance, and interest costs, offering a more complete picture of long-term commodity pricing.
Disadvantages of Contango
1. Negative Roll Yield
When traders roll expiring contracts into higher-priced futures, the price difference results in a loss over time — a major concern for futures-based strategies.
2. ETF Underperformance
Commodity ETFs that track futures often roll contracts monthly. In contango, these rollovers happen at higher prices, which can cause the fund to underperform the actual spot price of the asset.
3. Discourages Long-Term Holding
For investors seeking long exposure, contango adds a cost burden that reduces returns over time, making it less attractive for buy-and-hold strategies.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Backwardation
Backwardation can create favorable conditions for certain strategies but may also signal market stress. The following points outline its major benefits and risks.
Advantages of Backwardation
1. Positive Roll Yield
Traders benefit as futures prices rise toward the spot price at expiry, generating a potential return from contract rollovers.
2. Favorable for Long Positions
Investors entering long positions at discounted futures prices can gain an edge as prices rise closer to the spot.
3. Signals Strong Demand or Tight Supply
Backwardation often indicates immediate demand or supply shortages, providing bullish signals for short-term trading opportunities.
Disadvantages of Backwardation
1. Supply Risk and Market Stress
Backwardation may reflect underlying issues like geopolitical risk or inventory shortages, increasing market uncertainty.
2. Higher Market Volatility
Sharp changes in supply and demand can cause price swings, making backwardated markets more volatile and harder to predict.
3. Limited Hedging Flexibility
Lower future prices reduce incentives for producers to hedge, which can lead to more exposure to price fluctuations.
In Summary
Contango and backwardation are key concepts in futures trading that reflect market expectations, cost factors, and the balance of supply and demand. Understanding the differences between them helps traders and investors manage risk, interpret market signals, and make more informed decisions when dealing with futures contracts or commodity-based ETFs.
Start Trading Today with VT Markets
At VT Markets, we offer access to a wide range of futures-linked instruments and commodities through powerful platforms like MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5). Whether you’re trading energy, precious metals, or indices, our platform is built to support both new and experienced traders with competitive spreads and 24/5 access to our comprehensive Help Centre.
Explore market opportunities, test your strategies risk-free with a VT Markets demo account, and take advantage of advanced tools to navigate pricing structures like contango and backwardation with confidence.
Sign up today and trade smarter with VT Markets.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is contango in simple terms?
Contango is when futures prices are higher than the current spot price due to storage or financing costs.
2. What is backwardation in simple terms?
Backwardation is when futures prices are lower than the current spot price due to strong near-term demand or limited supply.
3. Can ETFs be affected by contango?
Yes. Commodity ETFs that roll futures contracts can suffer performance drag in contango markets.
4. How do I know if a market is in backwardation?
Check the futures curve. If short-term contracts are priced higher than long-term ones, it’s backwardation.
5. Why does contango result in negative roll yield?
In a contango market, rolling into a more expensive futures contract means buying high and selling low repeatedly, which erodes returns over time.
6. Can backwardation be sustained long-term?
Backwardation is often short-lived and driven by temporary factors like supply shocks or seasonal demand. It typically shifts back to contango as conditions normalize.
